Book Reviews

[review] Love & Haight – Susan Carlton

Release Date: March 13, 2012
Publisher: Henry Holt and Co. (Macmillan)
Age Group: Young Adult
Pages: 192
Format: Hardcover
Source: ARC received from publisher

It’s 1971, and seventeen-year-old Chloe and her best friend MJ head to San Francisco to ring in the New Year. But Chloe has an ulterior motive—and a secret. She’s pregnant and has devised a plan not to be. In San Francisco’s flower-power heyday, it was (just about) legal to end her pregnancy.

But as soon as the girls cross the Golden Gate, the scheme starts to unravel amid the bellbottoms, love-beads, and bongs. Chloe’s secrets escalate until she betrays everyone she cares about. MJ, who has grave doubts about Chloe’s plan. Her groovy aunt Kiki, who’s offered the girls a place to crash. Her self-absorbed mother meditating back in Phoenix. And maybe, especially, the boy she wishes she’d waited for.

Tell Me More: With the exception of Go Ask Alice, there are very few YA novels that attempt to tell the story of kids faced with the temptations of drugs, sex and “free love” in the last five decades. The taboo subjects that were only whispered about in the 1970s are now blurted out on social media without a thought. The internet has knocked down barriers to communication and knowledge, and it isn’t quite clear yet if that freedom will ultimately help or harm future generations. Susan Carlton makes a brave choice in writing about a teenager who makes reckless choices in an era where she had everything to lose.

Without delving into the morality of abortion, I will say that I was apprehensive about how Carlton would handle the emotional, mental and physical effects Chloe would encounter because of her choice. Stories like this aren’t cookie-cutter material, and writers can’t insert names and still make it a story worth reading. It becomes important to find a heart to the story, the reason for telling  it in the first place. If Chloe wasn’t flawed in a familiar and poignant way, there wouldn’t be a reason to care for her. Teens are notoriously stereotyped as apathetic and uninterested in anything but themselves. For Chloe to matter, they need to be able to see themselves in her. Carlton channels this need wonderfully, and makes it clear that there is always more at stake than we can see at any moment.

I was particularly impressed by her choice to use the third-person POV, instead of the easy out of a first-person narrative. Carlton trusts her readers to be smart and savvy as they follow Chloe to San Francisco. There’s no talking down to readers, which is why I would recommend teachers and parents be available to guide their teens through this story. It’s not explicit by any means, but there are questions that will come up and require some additional explanations.

In the end, the great potential of Love & Haight is defeated by the lack of length. There simply isn’t enough to satisfy readers, and while I wouldn’t want the story to go on forever, Chloe needed a bit more closure than she got.  I enjoyed the supporting characters immensely, and it would have been great to really tie them all together. The conflicts played out realistically, but I still felt like there was at least 20-25 pages left of story left to tell.

The Final Say: Love & Haight is a complicated and nuanced story of bravery and faith that will keep readers thinking long after they’ve closed the book.

About Susan

Susan Carlton was born in San Francisco, although (regrettably) she did not come of age in the hippie era. The author of the teen novel Lobsterland and a writer for magazines, including SelfElle, and Mademoiselle, she currently lives in Massachusetts with her husband. Her college-aged daughters know all the lyrics to Baba O’Riley.

Add Love & Haight on Goodreads | Visit Susan’s website

Order Love & Haight from Amazon | Book Depository | Chapters


3 replies »

  1. Wow this book sounds a lot deeper than I had expected based on the cover (once again reminding me not to judge a book by it’s cover). I like that it takes an issue that’s coming up a lot right now (at least in the US) but sets in the 1970s. Should add an interesting perspective.

  2. This book sounds intense and Susan Carlton definitely takes on something that is not seen anymore. It seems like it is a topic that is hard to write about and by the sound of your review, Susan does a great job (even though it could have been longer). I love the sound of this book (never heard of it before) and definitely need to look into it!

  3. I really did not enjoy Go Ask Alice…and I think similarly this book isn’t for me even though there are some mature and interesting themes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s